Three Taverns Church

Church Discipline: Series Introduction


Last night at the church where my recovery meetings take place I noticed a stack of freshly printed booklets set out prominently on the information desk.

I cannot reveal the name of the booklet or its author because either name might give away the location of my recovery group and thus violate its anonymity. However, I can tell you this:

  • The booklet was written by a long-time Senior Pastor
  • The booklet was originally written in 2002 and recently re-printed
  • The subject of the booklet is church discipline
  • There were approximately twenty of these booklets lying on the church’s Information Desk

As soon as I caught sight of the booklet’s title my blood pressure spiked. Church discipline, I thought, haven’t we seen enough of that? I’ll bet their ‘discipline’ doesn’t apply equally to everyone in the church. It doesn’t, by the way, but we’ll get to that in another post. I was recently threatened with church discipline for writing a post in this blog so I had to take a copy of this fascinating document home for further study.

This booklet scares me. My wife only read the first page and it scared her. The author seems very intelligent and well-versed in Scripture, and in my opinion he uses those gifts to threaten his church. It’s the worst kind of bullying there is and falls right in line with my recent series on religious rigidity.

I’m going to spend the next few days exploring the ideas put forth in the booklet. To start the series I want to quickly discuss the need for a church discipline policy.

Publishing a discipline policy is important inasmuch as you have ‘covered your bases’ should a problem arise within the church. If the policy is used as an operational document, that is, if it is actually used in disciplinary situations, then it has some organizational value. Publishing a church discipline policy also gives church members fair warning regarding what to expect should they face discipline.

That last point raises a critical question, though, doesn’t it? Why should a church need to discipline its members? If the policy existed for the personal, spiritual, and physical protection of individuals within the church I might support it. But as I will show in this series, the primary purpose of this booklet is to protect the church organization, and more to the point, to protect the church’s ruling class.

The document was written by the people governing the church and is enforced by those same people: They decide what constitutes impropriety; they decide who has violated the policy; they enforce the discipline. The church has appointed itself Judge, Jury, and Executioner. There is no system of checks-and-balances and the conflict of interest is staggering.

Do you think it is important for a church to have a published discipline policy? Why or why not?

As we open this series, what are your initial thoughts on the subject of ‘church discipline’?

5 thoughts on “Church Discipline: Series Introduction

  1. I most definitely have an opininion on this issue, Mongoose…but I will wait a minute or two to see what you have to say.

    Be careful what you say, though. You may be stricken if you badmouth the church’s authority, you know.

    Quaking, even?

  2. I guess we each need to find the church body that seems to fulfill the needs we have at each part of our faith journey. Some folks might feel the need for the structure that “discipline” provides. Hopefully they will grow out of that but it could also stifle them. Thank goodness for the Holy Spirit!

    I contend that the devil likes to keep Christians criticizing one another so that we don’t have time to bring non-believers to Jesus. He wants us to be busy fault- finding other Christians so he can have free reign with the unsaved. I hope that Christians realize that we, being one body, are shooting ourself in the arm or the foot, or the heart when we “shoot” one another.

    Sure, there’s plenty wrong within the body of Christ but isn’t it incredible that God chose us to be HIS body?! HE will take care of us. He forgives us 70×7 times. His mercies are new everyday for a reason! Let us pray for one another. That might be our greatest discipline.

    • Thanks for the comment, Mary. I think I hear what you’re saying: This series may be counter-productive because it falls into the trap that Satan has laid out, namely that I’m criticizing ‘the church’ rather than reaching non-believers. Is that the point you were trying to make?

      You have a point, and perhaps I came across too critically once again. For people who are fans of discipline, I doubt I’ll be able to change their minds…so then, what is the purpose of this series? Is it just to rant and rave at ‘the church’? That does sound like familiar behavior for me…

      Then again, perhaps I’ll be able two sway folks who are on the fence about church discipline, to turn their attention away from persecuting each other and toward loving each other and people outside the church. Perhaps I can make the case that every day Christians spend evaluating whether other members of the body should be ‘disciplined’ is a day wasted because the kingdom of God was not advanced.

      I’ll have to walk a fine line on this topic, for sure.

  3. Pingback: Church Discipline, Part 1: Accountability « rabidmongoose

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s